Love them
- Product description
- âš¡ Caffeine
- 💪 Protein
- 🌾 Fiber
- 🧠Vitamins + Taurine
- 🥜 Soft-Baked Texture
- Keep one on hand for the peanut butter craving that never quits
- Pair with your afternoon coffee for a caramel-peanut butter pick-me-up
- Toss one in your gym bag for post-workout refuel
- Warm it slightly for a gooey, peanut-butter-cup-style bite
- Share with a fellow peanut butter fan (if you're feeling generous)
Gator Crap
A Florida fan favorite for a reason — this one's a protein-infused peanut butter base loaded with peanut butter cup bits and a hit of caramel flavor. Think of it as what happens when our Peanut Butta Cup bar and Salted Caramel Pretzel bar had a baby.
Flavor Profile | Peanut Butter, Peanut Butter Cup Bits, Caramel
Texture & Feel | Soft-Baked with Loaded Peanut Butter Cup Pieces
Best For | Post-Workout Refuel, Afternoon Treat, Peanut Butter Cravings
Inspired By | A Florida Fan Favorite — Part Peanut Butta Cup, Part Salted Caramel Pretzel
Fuel Factor | Protein, Caffeine, and Taurine to Get You Through the Day
Gator Crap is packed with:
Lifestyle Suggestions
Also...
No gators were harmed in the making of this bar. However, if you visit our Florida office, we're a mile from a sports bar with excellent fried alligator bites — just saying.

Customer Reviews
Overall rating: 4.8 / 5 from 339 reviews.
Great name. Great bar.
Lisa L. 5/5 Verified
Love- takes care of all my Reeses Cup cravings!
Julie B. 5/5 Verified
ONE OF MY FAVORITES! SO GOOD, CHOCOLATE & PEANUT BUTTER CHEWY GOODNESS!
Keisha F. 5/5 Verified
This are one of my favorite ones! Love everything about them except when I only get a half of bar!
Debra S. 5/5 Verified
Gator crap is my absolute favorite bar- reminds me of peanut butter fudge.
Chyanne G. 5/5 Verified
My family and I love peanut butter and chocolate so we love to order this flavor when it’s available. Tastes great a little warmed up.
Beth A. 5/5 Verified
No chemical taste; delicious flavor!
Sue M. 5/5 Verified
I am officially addicted. Will definitely purchase again.
Debby S. 5/5 Verified
Oh so good 😋😋
Patricia B. 5/5 Verified
One of my favorites! Love the peanut butter cup flavored bars.
Jill S. 5/5 Verified
I've ordered these a few times before and they are always delicious. The Gator Crap is chocolately and caramely!
Jennifer F. 5/5 Verified
Gator Crap is the BEST Crap ever!! I love this flavor it's perfect in every single way!! I've been bitten by the gator and I'm not even upset about it!
Amy K. 5/5
So much better than a peanut butter cup!
Amber G. 5/5 Verified
Just when I think I found a new favorite, yet again I get surprised. I never thought that I would love these bars as much as I do. These are by far superior in every way. Can't wait to order more!
Debby S. 5/5 Verified
Best peanut butter based bar. This just gets so gooey and gooey in the microwave that you truly feel like you’re eating peanut butter batter. There is nothing better…… except for maybe red velvet flavor. That one is also tremendous.
Laura L. 5/5 Verified
This is a seasonal bar, so grab them while you can…they are very good for a meal or a snack!
Patrice R. 5/5 Verified
Love
Patricia S. 5/5 Verified
Great tasting
Heather U. 5/5 Verified
Delicious
Donna E. 5/5 Verified
One of my favorite bars for sure!!
Brittney M. 5/5 Verified
Delish
Kelly B. 5/5 Verified
One of the best flavors ever!
Amber G. 5/5 Verified
Another of my favorites - chocolate & peanut butter deliciousness!
Heather V. 5/5 Verified
I love the chewy salty and sweet goodness of Gator Crap bars!
Laurie G. 5/5 Verified
Peanut butter Carmel perfection!! This bar is positively fantastic and my top peanut butter based bar.
Laura L. 5/5 Verified
Delicious bar one of my favs purchased a few times.
Mary D. 5/5 Verified
A favorite for sure. Any of the bars that are peanut butter cup related are a go-to for me.
Jill S. 5/5 Verified
Another one of my faves. Yummy!
Pam H. 5/5 Verified
Gator Crap is the absolute best PEANUT butter you can buy from Dive. It’s incredible and makes me want to eat 5 at a time…..In reality I have lost weight using Dive Bars and gained my health back!!
Laura L. 5/5
Gator Crap is one of my fav flavors. So good warmed up!! 🤩🤩🤩
Andrea H. 5/5 Verified
Gator Crap is one of the BEST peanut butter base bars. It’s so fantastic and ooey gooey yum in the microwave
Laura L. 5/5
Tastes just like a Reese’s peanut butter cup!!
Becky M. 5/5 Verified
Yummy and different. One of my top 5.
Nicole H. 5/5 Verified
Great!
Carrie H. 5/5 Verified
One of my favorites next to Lemon and KEY lime. Great flavor!!
Vickie J. 5/5 Verified
This is my new favorite and hope its available year round!
Colleen K. 5/5 Verified
Very surprising I liked the caramel chips Very good
Laura G. 5/5 Verified
I love this bar- please keep it on repeat!
Lisa M. 5/5 Verified
Gator crap is the best! Bits of chocolate and caramel, bring it back as a regular!
Janet F. 5/5 Verified






